Pulled Pork on the Kamado With Apple Cider Vinegar Sauce and Grilled Coleslaw

Kamado Pulled Pork With Apple Cider Vinegar Sauce and Grilled Coleslaw

Some grilled dishes demand a little patience and quite a lot of faith. Pulled pork is one of them. For the first hours almost nothing happens, then everything happens at once, and suddenly you’re standing there with a piece of meat that falls apart just from you looking at it. I like that journey. It isn’t fast food, but it isn’t hard either, as long as you do the right things in the right order.

This version is made for you if you want real BBQ feel at home but still keep it understandable. We cook pork collar low and slow in the kamado, build bark with a simple rub, spray lightly with apple juice and finish with a fresh apple cider vinegar sauce that cuts nicely through the fat. With it we make a grilled coleslaw that actually tastes of the grill and not just of the fridge.

This isn’t the recipe you pick when you’re hungry in 45 min. This is the recipe you pick when you want the whole day to smell of smoke, embers and anticipation. And once the guests sink their teeth into it, nobody tends to ask why it took so long.

About This Recipe

This recipe makes about 8 servings and works best when you have 10 h–12 h to work with, plus resting time. Pork collar is forgiving because it has enough fat to stay juicy even after a long cook. The apple cider vinegar sauce keeps the whole thing from getting heavy, and the coleslaw brings both crunch and a bit of charred grill flavor.

If you want to nerd out about which smoke suits pork best, our guide to smoking wood is well worth a few minutes before you light the grill.

Why You Should Try This Recipe

• You get real low and slow BBQ with clear temperatures and a plan you can follow.
• The apple cider vinegar sauce lightens the meat instead of drowning it in sweet sauce.
• Grilled coleslaw brings acidity, crunch and a distinct grilled flavor that suits the pork perfectly.
• The recipe works just as well in buns, tortillas, baked potatoes or simply straight on a cutting board.

Recipe: Pulled Pork on the Kamado With Apple Cider Vinegar Sauce and Grilled Coleslaw

MetricUS

Jump to instructions

Ingredients

For the Pulled Pork

• 5 ½ lb pork collar (pork neck), in one piece
• 2 tbsp neutral oil

For the Rub

• 2 tbsp paprika
• 2 tbsp brown sugar
• 1 tbsp flaky salt
• 2 tsp coarsely ground black pepper
• 2 tsp onion powder
• 2 tsp garlic powder
• 1 tsp ground cumin
• 1 tsp dry mustard
• ½ tsp cayenne pepper

For the Spray

• ¾ cup + 1½ tbsp apple juice
• ⅓ cup + 1½ tbsp apple cider vinegar

For the Apple Cider Vinegar Sauce

• ½ cup + 2 tbsp apple cider vinegar
• ⅓ cup + 1½ tbsp water
• 2 tbsp ketchup
• 1 tbsp brown sugar
• 1 tsp Dijon mustard
• 1 tsp chili flakes
• ½ tsp black pepper
• ½ tsp salt

For the Grilled Coleslaw

• 10½ oz pointed cabbage or white cabbage
• 2 carrots
• 1 small red onion
• ⅓ cup + 1½ tbsp mayonnaise
• ⅓ cup + 1½ tbsp crème fraîche
• 1 tbsp Dijon mustard
• 1 tbsp apple cider vinegar
• 1 tsp honey
• salt and black pepper

For Serving

• 8 brioche buns or potato buns
• pickled red onion, if you like
• extra sauce on the side

Instructions

1. Mix all the rub ingredients. Pat the meat dry with paper towels, brush with a little oil and massage the rub in thoroughly all around the piece. Preferably let the meat sit in the fridge for 8 h–12 h, but at least 1 h if time is short.
2. Light the kamado for indirect grilling and aim for 230–250°F in the grill. Add a couple of chunks of apple, or a mix of apple and hickory, once the embers are stable.
3. Place the meat on the grate with a drip pan underneath. Insert a thermometer in the thickest part. Close the lid and let the grill do its work.
4. Mix apple juice and apple cider vinegar in a spray bottle. When the bark starts to set, usually after 3 h, you can spray very lightly every 45 minutes. It should moisten the surface, not rinse off the spices.
5. When the meat reaches about 158–167°F, you often enter the stall phase. When the internal temperature feels frozen in place in the middle of the night, you can calm your pulse with the walkthrough of The Stall.
6. At 167–172°F, when the bark has a nice color, you can wrap the meat in butcher paper or foil if you want to shorten the cook a little. Keep going until the internal temperature is around 198–203°F and the meat feels tender when you probe it.
7. Let the meat rest at least 45 min, preferably 1 h, before pulling it apart. Save the meat juices that collect in the paper or foil.
8. Bring all the sauce ingredients to a boil in a small saucepan and let simmer for 5 min–7 min. Taste so the balance of acidity, saltiness and a little heat is right.
9. Cut the cabbage into large wedges, brush with a little oil and grill quickly over high direct heat until you get color but still have some bite left. Then shred it finely and mix with grated carrots, thinly sliced red onion and the dressing.
10. Pull the meat apart with your hands or two forks. Mix in a little of the saved meat juice and a few tablespoons of the vinegar sauce. Serve in grilled buns with coleslaw and extra sauce on the side.

Grilling Method: How to Succeed on the Grill

The secret here isn’t a secret ingredient. It’s even heat. You want a stable indirect setup where the meat has time to break down the collagen slowly without the outside drying out. A kamado is extra forgiving because it holds heat so well, but the principle is the same whatever grill you use: calm temperature, closed lid and patience.

If you’re new to low and slow, read through grilling methods first, and building a calm, stable indirect zone becomes much easier.

Don’t spray too often. I know it feels proactive, but every time you open the lid you lose heat, and every time you wet the surface too much you delay the bark. A light mist is enough. If you want even deeper smokiness, you can add a bit more wood early in the cook, but avoid feeding in smoke late, when the surface has already set.

Temperature, Time and Signs That It’s Done

• Grill temperature: 230–250°F
• Estimated time: 10 h–12 h for 5 ½ lb, sometimes longer
• The stall usually shows up around 158–167°F
• Finished internal temperature: 198–203°F
• Rest: at least 45 min

The most important sign isn’t an exact number but the feel. When the thermometer or a thin skewer slides in with almost no resistance, the meat is done. If it still feels bouncy or tough at 198°F, it needs more time. Pulled pork is done when the collagen gives up, not when the clock says so.

Which Grill Works Best?

A kamado is my first choice for this recipe, because it’s economical with fuel and stable over a long time. A kettle grill also works very well if you set it up for indirect heat and add fuel smartly. A pellet grill makes the job easy. A gas grill can work with a smoker box and patience, but you’ll rarely get quite the same depth of smoke.

If you want to compare with a more classic style, there’s also Real Pulled Pork to read on.

Serving Suggestions

The most obvious choice is grilled buns, coleslaw and extra vinegar sauce, but don’t stop there. Pulled pork is fantastic in soft tortillas with pickled onion and cilantro, in a baked potato with sour cream, or on a platter with corn, jalapeños and beans when you want to feed a crowd. I also like serving it with roasted new potatoes and a simple cucumber salad when you want to cut back on bread but keep the feeling of a summer dinner on the patio.

If you have guests who like to build their own plate, this is a dream recipe. Put out the meat, the slaw, bread, pickled onion, cucumber and sauces and let everyone build their own version. It comes across as generous without feeling stiff.

Björn’s Tips

• Don’t be stingy with the salt. A big piece of meat needs more seasoning than you first think.
• Open the lid as seldom as you can. Curiosity is BBQ’s most expensive spice.
• Always save the meat juices from the rest and mix a little back into the pulled meat. A lot of flavor sits there.

Common Mistakes

• Too high a grill temperature. The outside turns dark too fast while the inside doesn’t have time to get tender.
• Pulling too early. If the meat doesn’t feel properly soft, the result is stringy instead of juicy.
• Too much sweet sauce. It wipes out both the smoke and the flavor of the meat.
• No rest. If you pull the meat apart straight away, a lot of liquid runs off for nothing.

Variations and Adaptations

If you want more heat, you can add more chili flakes to the sauce or a little cayenne to the rub. For a rounder, sweeter style, you can swap part of the vinegar for apple juice in the sauce. If you don’t have pointed cabbage, white cabbage works fine, and if you want a lighter slaw, you can swap half of the mayonnaise for extra crème fraîche or Greek yogurt. The recipe can also be made with picnic shoulder, but expect a slightly different cooking time and a little less fattiness.

Why This Recipe Works

Pulled pork lives on the interplay between fat, collagen, smoke and acidity. Pork collar has enough marbling to stay juicy over a long time, but only if you let it go long enough. As the meat passes the higher internal temperatures, the connective tissue starts to break down properly, and that’s when you get that stringy but juicy texture that lets you pull it apart with your fingers.

The rub builds bark through saltiness, a little sweetness and spices that stand up to a long cook. The brown sugar helps the color but isn’t so dominant that the meat turns into dessert. The smoking wood adds depth to the outside early in the cook, while the spray helps keep the surface from drying out completely. The vinegar sauce is needed to cut through both fat and smoke. Without it, the whole thing risks being flat and heavy. The coleslaw then does two jobs at once: it gives crunch against the soft meat and lifts every bite with freshness.

It’s exactly that balance that makes you happily take one more bite. Fat gets acid in reply, softness gets crunch, smoke gets freshness and bark gets a creamy contrast in the slaw. It’s simple BBQ logic, but when it clicks, it’s very hard to beat.

FAQ

Can I make pulled pork on a gas grill?

Yes, but build a clear indirect zone and use a smoker box or smoker tube. Expect a little less smoke flavor than on a kamado or smoker.

Do I have to wrap the meat?

No. You can go completely without paper or foil if you have the time. You’ll usually get slightly drier but more distinct bark. Wrapping is mostly a way to save time and hold on to moisture.

Can I prepare it the day before?

Absolutely. Pulled pork is often even better the next day. Reheat gently with a little saved meat juice or apple juice so it stays juicy.

Which smoking wood is best for pulled pork?

Apple, cherry and hickory are classics. I like apple for a mild sweetness, and a bit of hickory if I want more classic BBQ weight.

How do I know the meat is done if the thermometer shows the right temperature but it feels tough?

Then it isn’t done yet. Pulled pork should feel soft when you probe it. Temperature is a signpost, not the answer key.

Once you’ve made pulled pork a few times, you notice it isn’t magic, just time and control. But it still feels a little like magic when you lift the lid and everything is just as it should be.